Rhone 2010 - Greater than 2009?

I look forward to the Rhone buying trip with particular relish. The place is beautiful, the weather a welcome change from grey London and the diverse array of wines fantastic. Rhone can never be accused of being boring, from the divergent blends of Chateauneuf, the varying styles of the Northern Syrahs, not to mention Condrieu, Marsannes and Roussannes. What's more I know that when I get back home, there will be more than a few things on my wine shopping list that I will actually be able to afford.

This July's aim was to re-taste 2009s and take an extensive look at 2010s. The schedule in front of me was bursting at the seams, 22 growers in 4 days including Clos des Papes,Pegau, Vieux Telegraphe, Chave, Domaine du Coulet, Alain Graillot, Rostaing, Clusel Roch and Stephane Ogier to name a few. I am very much becoming a victim of the Rhone's success, it seems that every year we add a new grower to the portfolio. The trip left me quite exhausted, albeit in a thoroughly satisifed way.

2009s are showing just as well as a year ago if not better, it is a rich vintage north and south, a show stopper, a vintage of opulence and seduction. For me the wines of the year, north or south, were those of Rene Rostaing, though the fabulous Chave 09s (to be released next year) will be snapping at Rostaing's heals.

As for 2010, well all I can say is that, taken as a whole, Rhone 2010 is greater than 2009. In the south, thanks to coulure, it is a very small vintage but the quality is excellent. The wines have the ripeness of 2009, the concentration, but more freshness and balance. Indeed they approach the 2007s in depth and will supercede them for drinkability. I thought Versino/ Bois de Boursan was particularly successful, as was Pegau, Vieux Telegraphe and le Bois Pointu (now made by Domaine Etienne Gonnet)

In the North, 2010 is a truely great year, whether greater than 09 depends on the individual producer. It is a very close call between the two in Cote Rotie particularly, whereas in Hermitage and Cornas I almost unanimously preferred the crisp, more defined and elegant structures of the 2010s. Rene Rostaing again came up trumps with an outstanding range, Francois Villard I think has made his best ever vintage, red and white, whilst the lovable Clusel Rochs have pulled a very special vintage out of the bag. Faurie and Domaine du Colombier (whose freshly ripened apricots were out of this world!) performed brilliantly and one of my very favourite growers Mathieu Barret of Domaine du Coulet, has yet again made stunning Cornas, far better than many Hermitages. For me Cornas is one France's most underrated appellations.

So there we have it, a great vintage and, hopefully, probably, maybe.... reasonable prices. Our full offer of 2010s will be launched in November.

Next stop Spain in a week's time, follow the action on twitter @gilesbg

Mont Redon Cotes du Rhone 09

17 points from at a mere £65 cs ib.

Having sent out a mailer on the deliciousness of Mont Redon's 2009 Cotes du Rhone, it was nice to read Julia Harding's similarly complimentary view of this excellent value little wine on www.jancisrobinson.com

"Ch Mont-Redon 2009 Côtes du Rhône 17 Drink 2011-2014
Bottled. Fresh dark fruit leaps from the glass. Dark cherry and plum. Wonderfully juicy within a well-judged framework. Tannins and acidity both clearly present but playing a supporting role to all that lovely fruit. Fine bite on the end and a long finish. (JH) 14%
£65 per case ib Justerini & Brooks"

Rhone 2009 - The Septentrional Slog

After two days of Meridional marathon in the Southern Rhone, I embarked on an even more gruelling two days in the Septentrional North. I have visited 7 producers both yesterday and today(thursday)taking in the best of Cornas, Crozes, St Joseph, Hermitage, Condrieu, Cote Rotie and that well known Vin de Pays, Seyssuel! I have seen all of our regulars such as Chave, Domaine du Coulet, Domaine du Colombier, Perret and Rostaing to name a few, as well as keeping an eye on the regions young (winemaking!) talents, people such as Semaska, PJ Villa and Stephane Ogier. That makes 26 producers in 4 days. Now, before you all sarcastically get your violins out, actually this has not been such a tall order. Glancing at my schedule upon arriving late into Marseille on Sunday, I thought I had gone perhaps a touch o.t.t., but in fact the style and quality of this vintage has really made it feel rather effortless.

Whilst 09 is a small vintage in the south because of the very few bunches of Grenache that had formed on the vines, in the north it is a vintage of quality and quantity like 1999. Some producers in Cornas prefer the elegance of 08 to the richness of 09, remember that this appellation's sheer, exposed and well-drained slopes produced very good 2008s. 2009s in Cornas are enormously rich and intense, some top the charts at 15 degrees alcohol, too much wine for some people perhaps, but I am sure they will earn great critical acclaim in some quarters. Domaine du Coulet have made an incredible Gore Cuvee this year. St Joseph is particularly high performing, i think, perhaps some of the most balanced wines of the vintage, Perret's Grisieres is sublime and Villard has made the vintage of his life, in my opinion. Rene Rostaing was ebullient and rightly so, all three of his Cuvees were exemplary. Clusel Roch will be releasing a very serious Grandes Places aswell as a separate bottling of, for the first time, La Viaillere which that i thought remarkable and one of my personal favourites of the trip.

For anyone who remembers and still has examples of that great 1999 Northern Rhone vintage, I tasted a Grandes Places 99 with Brigitte Roch. On the basis of this 99s are every bit as wonderful as they were on release. Really impressive, one of the greats, but worth holding onto for at least another 5 - 10 years, it is still so young.

2009 - High Spirits in Chateauneuf du Pape

Monday and Tuesday have gone remarkably quickly and smoothly despite the crammed schedule. Chateauneuf is starting to feel like my second home now, my visits have inlcuded pierre usseglio, pegau, barroche, versino, vieux telegraphe, rayas, beaucastel, cros de la mure, clos des cazaux cayron, and clos des papes. Phew, thats a lot of grenache! Everyone seems really very content with their 09s if a bit rushed because 2010 is behind schedule and there is lots to do in the vineyard. The 09 wines our gorgeously lush open and fruity, even the usually more reductive styles are showing well. This is clearly a very good vintage,different to 2007 less black fruit and in many cases less alcohol, which was a pleasant surprise, though still quite high nonetheless, domaines like usseglio have produced wine at about 14.5 alc versus 15+ in 07.No doubt some 09s will be much higher than this, however. The profile of the 09s are rich incredibly smooth more red fruit perhaps than the black fruit of 07. There is definitely tannic power but this is hidden by glycerol and fruit sweetness. However tannins and minerality do seem to give the impression of freshness, for the best wines are certainly not heavy or sickly. Many growers, namely Vincent Avril of Clos des Papes, consider it as in between 2007 and 2005 in style, the sweetness of the former and the structure of the latter without being as rigid or austere as 2005. Mourvedre, Counoise and the cooler grenache zones have done particularly well

A word on 08s. Dismissing this as another 02 is plainly wrong. My tastings in bottle of the southern rhones over the last two days reaffirmed my barrel tastings. Ok there will have been some bad wines in this challenging vintage, but it is surprising how lovely the wines from the good growers are. Ripe, floral, refreshing acids and decent mid-weight smooth structures. Not one of the greats but as good as very nice vintages such as 1999 (or better for some like Vincent Avril)